Is the cooling upgrade worth it?
Your 2 finalists.
Checking for your sleep profile…
| 2 mattresses | ||
|---|---|---|
| Independent ratings on fileReviewer ratings out of 10 from the sources listed on each mattress page. They are not Match Scores; a Match Score needs your sleep profile. | ||
| CoolingSame for all | Data unavailable | Data unavailable |
| Motion isolation | 7.5/10 | 8/10Leads |
| Edge support | 6.5/10Leads | 6/10 |
| Durability | 5.5/10 | 6.5/10Leads |
| Feel and construction | ||
| FirmnessOn a 1–10 scaleSame for all | Medium5.5/10 | Medium5.5/10 |
| TypeSame for all | All-foam | All-foam |
| Height | 14 in | 10 in |
| LayersAs described by the manufacturer | Costco spec sheet: "Gel Memory Foam"; marketing bullets add "Cooling Gel Memory Foam Plus Cool Touch Cover." No layer-by-layer density breakdown stated. | Breathable Knit Cover (87% polyester/13% viscose) or optional Cooling Quilt Top upgrade; 2" GreenFlex BioFoam (3lb, USDA BioPreferred); 2" Ultra-Supportive Memory Foam (3lb); 6" Durable Support Foam; fiberglass-free fire barrier |
| Price and policies | ||
| Queen pricePrice on the brand’s page when checked; may be a sale priceSame for all | Not yet verified | Not yet verified |
| Sleep trial | Not yet verified | 120 nights |
| Warranty | Not yet verified | Lifetime |
| Data statusHow much of this record is checkedSame for all | Data unavailable | Data unavailable |
Specs come from manufacturer sources and independent reviews on file. Anything we haven’t confirmed says so. Thumbnails are illustrations of each mattress type, not product photos.
Best for you
Scoring your finalists…
Popular comparisons
Head to head, already scored.
Curated pairs that answer a real shopping question, each scored by the engine for four disclosed reference sleepers. How scoring works
All-foam or hybrid, same brand.
Casper The One vs Casper Dream
Two all-foam grids, one thicker and softer.
The Purple Mattress vs PurplePlus
The same grid over foam, or over coils.
PurplePlus vs Purple Restore Hybrid
Two all-foam beds under $1,000.
Casper The One vs Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress II
A firmer value hybrid against a medium one.
DreamCloud Classic Hybrid Mattress vs Casper Dream
Two hybrids built for heavier sleepers.
Helix Plus vs Big Fig Classic Mattress
Two premium all-foam beds, one runs warmer.
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt vs PurplePlus
Profile shortlists
A disclosed demo profile, run through the same engine, with its top three side by side.
Side sleepers under $1,000
A side sleeper on a firm budget: 155 lb, sleeps hot, and wants to spend $1,000 or less on a Queen. Only mattresses with a published Queen price at or below that line are scored.
- Side sleeper
- 155 lb
- Prefers medium-firm
- Sleeps hot
Cooling hybrids for couples
Two people sharing a bed, one a light sleeper, both running warm. Only hybrids are considered: the coil-and-foam builds that couples who sleep hot often shortlist.
- Side sleeper
- 180 lb
- Prefers medium-firm
- Sleeps hot
Motion isolation for couples
A back sleeper who shares the bed and wakes when a partner turns over. Every type is eligible, and motion isolation counts for twice its default weight.
- Back sleeper
- 180 lb
- Prefers medium-firm
- Neutral temperature
Pressure relief for side sleepers
A side sleeper who wakes with sore shoulders and hips and likes a soft bed. There is no budget or type filter, so every mattress in the catalog is scored.
- Side sleeper
- 160 lb
- Prefers soft
- Neutral temperature
Back support for heavier sleepers
A 240 lb back sleeper who wants a firm bed and has lower-back focus. Every type is eligible; support and durability carry extra weight.
- Back sleeper
- 240 lb
- Prefers firm
- Neutral temperature